Friday, September 15, 2006

Terrorism
Case Study: Sabra and Shatila camps
Time: 16-17-18 Sep 1982


A few months back in Tehran Int’l Book Fair, I bought a few books on Palestine and Israel. I will write about them one by one- whenever I had the mood and time.

They were all very good and for such an ignorant girl I am, had lots of things to teach. One of them was Sabra and Shatila, September 1982 written by a Palestinian lady – Bayan Nuwayhed al-Hout about the massacre Lebanese rightists committed, backed and organized by Israeli forces occupying Beirut in 1982.
Well, before reading the book, I just knew a hazy story of the reality including that the Palestinian refugees were massacred in Sabra and Shatila camps when Mr Sharon was supervising the ‘operation’ from a building having a good view on the entire site of massacre in Sep 82.
Reading the book, I learned a lot more. But reading it was really challenging and I had to concentrate a huge amount of energy to go on. Sometimes just amid a page describing a scene, I closed the book and tried to overcome my anger and sorrow squeezing my heart so badly wiping my river of tears. The brutality and the savagery were enormous- far more than what my heart could bear with.
The book is a very careful and detailed investigation on the massacre, interviewing tens of people who witnessed it and those who survived it. Beside the survived people, the interviews goes on with medics (there were some hospitals just close to the site), the volunteers who helped to bury the corpses, the members of aid organizations going to the camps right after the massacre and many other groups whom I don’t remember. Also it quotes from journalists’ reports who visited the camps when they were allowed to go in. Robert Fisk was one of them.

The massacre began on Sep 14, went on all during Sep 15 and ended on Sep 16 when in some parts, it even was not finished then. It not only took place in the camps, but also was extended to the area around and to the hospitals adjacent to the site.

Ms al-Hout lived in Beirut then as a Palestinian refugee in another corner of the city and began to work on the investigation project right after the massacre. She gives a detailed report on the procedure of interviews. Since many who survived were panicked by the horrible scenes they had experienced, they were reluctant to speak about it. Those who were courageous enough, accepted to go to the writer’s place to be interviewed by her. The technology was not that improved then. All the interviews were recorded on cassettes and then were written down by brave volunteers. Then, when the situation loosened a bit, Ms al-Hout went to camps and began to speak to people there.
As said before, the book is a careful and accurate research on all the incidents told by those who had witnessed it and had survived the massacre. So, the book includes accurate details on the interviewees, the place of interview, etc. Those who were terrified were given a chance to keep hidden by a nickname.
The book reveals that the massacre was backed and supported by Israelis. They surrounded the camps and lit the site with projectors to help the ‘operation’ to go on even during the night. Ms al-Hout gives exact locations of Israelis and many other details and proves that all the claims regarding the Israelis’ ignorance on the circumstances in the camps are big fat lies.
Despite what I thought, the victims were not just Palestinians. As the camps were the poor areas of Beirut, it was the residence of many other poor people who couldn’t afford good places to rent. So, when the biggest number of the butchered people goes to Palestinian, Lebanese were not few. Beside them, other nationalities were among the killed; Egyptians, Yemenis, Bangladeshis and Pakistanis and many other nationalities. To my surprise, I even saw an Iranian name. His occupation: baker.

A few days back a lady from Latin America left a comment here telling about ‘terrorism’. I invite her to read this book to know what actually terrorism means and who represents it in our world.

11 Comments:

At 2:02 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Well Laila,

So who is the real terrorist in the world? You can say it. It is OK.

In the way you are pointing the events of Sabra and Shatila massacre, the 400,000 Israelis who went to demonstrate, calling to investigate the events, suggesting an Israeli military responsibility in that horrible massacre, are terrorists as well?

What about the people who made that massacre, the Maronite Christian Militias commanded by Elie Hobeika? Did you forget about them? Why don’t you mention that Sabra and Shatila was not the first and not the last massacre in Lebanon? There where much more of them, had nothing to do with Israel.

In that way Laila, showing the reality just from one side, or just against one side, people in that world doesn’t have a chance for peace. The only thing you can achieve is just more hate.

I’m just waiting for the day 400,000 Iranians will demonstrate in the center of Tehran against crimes gains humanity as was made by Hezbollah (as defined recently by Amnesty International) against Israelis citizens, or against the president of Iran Mr. Mahmoud Ahmadinejad claiming for the elimination of Israel.

Ah…you know what. Say nothing for the right of Israelis to live. I’ll be done with a demonstration in Iran calling for human rights of Iranians.

In that day I’ll know that there is a chance for peace in the world.

Salam,
Lot.

 
At 4:01 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

In response to the above comments,
400,000 Iranians who have the guts to stand up are in prison or executed or fled and suffer discrimination all over the world.

some try to hide their head in the books hoping that some day they wake up and those exiles come back and change the situation for them. Unfortunately the documentary film that is now available on how the mullahs kill the dissident Iranians at home and abroad one by one is in Persian. You might understand it from the pictures (there is some German in the background in some parts). Ahamadinejad should focus on eliminiation of poverty, child labor, capital punishment, and many other issues in Iran instead of making such provocative remarks about Israel. He is just a puppet any how the ultimate power is with the
khamenei and his ignorant mullahs

 
At 12:26 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Dear Anather Iranian,

Thanks for your comment. You have just made my point.

Good Week
Lot.

 
At 1:10 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Dear Laila:

I would read with pleasure the books you’ve commented about if you could please write their references.

Responding to your comment (“A few days back a lady from Latin America left a comment here telling about ‘terrorism’. I invite her to read this book to know what actually terrorism means and who represents it in our world”) and its relationship with the article you wrote I’m supposed to understand from you the real terrorist is Israel. Well, as far as I read the Lebanese Maronite Christian militias made the massacre in 1982. We can discuss how Israel is blamed for conspiracy but we cannot agree, since it’s a very controversial statement, that this massacre was “backed and organized by Israeli forces occupying Beirut in 1982”. (See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sabra_and_Shatila_massacre for more details).

I must admit I got kind of confused by your comment. I would have thought in a beginning you were upset, and sad by all the deaths caused in the massacre (with right to be). After I read between 1975 and 1990 (period of a civil war in Lebanon) the total death in Lebanon was up to 100,000 victims I felt very sad too. I have in my mind the idea of a beautiful Lebanon with high cultural level people with whom we have good relationship. However, after reading the whole article I understood the focus of it was not other than just to blame Israel for its apparently complicity. I think we are coming back to the same point I talked about in the last comment I made about Sept 11 when talking about the United States and terrorism. We could blame if we wanted Lebanon, and Syria (without being sure there was not participation of Iran) for their involvement in the organization of some bombs attacks in Argentina in which many people died (understanding of course that Argentina is far from being in the Middle East conflict). I can also name people who died (to show they are not just numbers), such as a little boy called Sebastian Barreiros, who was in his way to the kindergarten when this happened. I can definitely say what happened there was “terrorism” by definition and accuse the other side of the world of being terrorist. However, I understand a group of militants is not representative of a whole nation. Not so a military is representative of the nation when he is acting against his commands (“on September 25, 300,000 Israelis — roughly one tenth of the country's then-population — demonstrated in Tel Aviv demanding answers”.” On September 28, the Israeli Government resolved to establish a Commission of Inquiry, which was led by former Supreme Court Justice Kahan”…” the commission found that Ariel Sharon "bears personal responsibility" and recommended his dismissal from the post of Defense Minister; it also recommended the dismissal of Director of Military Intelligence Yehoshua Saguy, and the effective demotion of Division Commander Amos Yaron for at least three years….”- See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sabra_and_Shatila_massacre for more details).

If Israel had responsibility on it, it was assumed by its own people and responsible were charged and dismissed of their positions. However, Argentinean people are still claiming for justice for all of those who died in the “terrorist attacks”.

You have the same right to say an officer in an army was a “terrorist” as I can say a militant group from Syria and Lebanon is also a “terrorist”. But none of those statements now will lead us to any useful conclusion. All of these will just lead us to more hate, to more “terror” and more death. We are talking here about victims who died, and a comment like yours is very dangerous since it can feed anger which can be turned into actions that will produce more other people to die. I would have liked today to see an article that calls people to take conscious of a horrible massacre which happened in Lebanon. I would like people of Lebanon to be free from any terrorist group which is attempting against their rights, but it will just be up to them. And it’s up to us to transmit positive values towards life, tolerance and peace, and not more death. It’s up to us to stop this horrible cycle of “no point” discussions giving turns around history and to turn our thinking into how to solve people’s differences to be able to live with respect, dignity, tolerance and freedom. This is the world I’d like to leave to our kids.

Regards from the third world

Mariana

 
At 1:33 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Dear “another Iranian”:

I was not aware there were so many problems in Iran concerning freedom, specially knowing you were having free elections. I feel there is so much I have to learn about….but I can just tell you that at the moment a majority of Iranians will stop blaming other nations and will change their mentality in order to claim for better life conditions and freedom in Iran, there will not be repressor who will be able to stop you!!... I can tell you that at the moment most of the people in my country started to feel there was “nothing else to loose”, at the moment those who were in the exile went to the human rights organization to claim for international intervention to protect civilians and accuse the horrible practices of the government. At the moment some “mothers” decided there was no surrender till their children would appear, and the country got devastated but the human loses of a war….When people understood their action was imminent to finish that regime….then it was the end of the dictatorship….

I wish you will not have to reach such a harm to take conscience that a change it’s up to you…as a unit... and that the only one way to take conscience of this is by educating people...

Regards

Mariana

 
At 1:48 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Dear "Lot"

thank you

you might be interested to read my comment under the "9/11" article in the bog,

1irany or just another iranian

 
At 9:30 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

have you seen these online videos

http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-3319967978568410735&q=bush&hl=en

-------------------------------------------------------
http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-3934788900154749704&q=bush&hl=en

or just search bush under google videos
-------------------------------
bush and ahmadinejad have a lot in common:
level of IQ
ability to provoke the world into kaos
hillarious
abbility to present intelligent speeches
together they can destroy our planet
......

 
At 11:23 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

a poem from my all time hero

Khosrow Golesorkhi, (b.Rasht 1322/1943 d.Tehran 1353/1974), poet, journalist, and revolutionary... , if he was not executed by the despotic regim of shah, he would been the best candidate for nobel prize (he is from the same generation as shirin ebadi).

why why the best had to be killed by shah and later by the mullahs
her is a brief part of his court
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Oug9e8Jperg

dear laila if you or anyone have access to his full interview please please post it on youtube.com

 
At 12:38 PM, Blogger Laila said...

Thanks for coming and commenting. I will answer them tomorrow. Just to tell you Mariana that if you click on the name of the book in the post, you will be directed to amazon where the book can be bought.

 
At 3:41 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Dear Laila,

Have you heard that story?

"When the troops moved in, the first item on the agenda was to dislodge the LNM
from the Kesrouan mountains and force them to retreat. In June of 1976 this
item was accomplished, and in August 1976, a move on Tel-elzaatar was taking
place with Syrian assistance. The Phalangists and company moved to irradicate
the Dbieyeh and Jisr al Basha camps. With the departure of Arab troops from
Lebanon in the summer of 1977, the second goal of authority restoration became
sort of a Syrian mandate. A Syrian militia emerged instead of an extension to
the Lebanese regime as an aid in imposing the authority of the regime. The
important thing to see here is that Syria operated under an endorsed mandate by
the Arab League as well as the weakened government and some power breakers in
Lebanon. Here lies the big difference between Syrian presence and the Israeli
occupation of 1978, 1982 and so on."

http://groups.google.com/group/soc.culture.lebanon/tree/browse_frm/month/1994-01?_done=%2Fgroup%2Fsoc.culture.lebanon%2Fbrowse_frm%2Fmonth%2F1994-01%3F&

Lot

 
At 5:26 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

See www.terrorfreetomorrow.org

Look under "What's New" for an interesting new public opinion poll of Iran

 

Post a Comment

<< Home